Smart #3 review

Smart #3 review

Smart’s all-electric renaissance continues with the sleek #3 family SUV…

The Smart #3 (pronounced “Hashtag Three”) is the second model from the brand which is now a joint venture between Mercedes-Benz and Chinese giant Geely (also the owner of Volvo, Polestar and Lotus).

Unusually, the Smart #3 has few direct rivals because of its dimensions and pricing.

In other words, it’s about the same size as the £50k Volvo EC40, yet because it starts at just £33,960, it’s also up against smaller EVs including the Volkswagen ID.3.

Smart #3 review

The Smart #3 is one of an increasing number of “coupe-SUVs” such as the Peugeot E-3008 and Volkswagen ID.5. I’m not sure about the use of the word “coupe”, but they do have lower, sloping rooflines and swept-back hatches.

They say beauty is in the eye of the beholder, so I’ll let you decide on the #3’s styling. All I would say is that it’s certainly distinctive and the rear has a hint of the Mercedes-Benz EQA about it.

The Smart #3 comes in four trim levels – Pro, Pro , Premium, and the top-spec Brabus performance-focused model.

Smart #3 review

Pro uses a smaller 48kWh battery compared to the 62kWh unit found in the other #3 models.

Smart claims a WLTP range of 202 miles for the Pro, with the Pro offering 270 miles and the Premium achieving 283 miles. These three all use a 268bhp electric motor mounted on the rear axle, and are capable of 0-62mph in 5.8 seconds and a top speed of 112mph.

The bonkers Brabus adds another electric motor on the front axle (making it all-wheel drive), producing 422bhp and 543Nm of torque for a neck-wrenching 0-62mph time of 3.7 seconds, though range is reduced to 258 miles.

Smart #3 review

I’ll be honest, I thought the Smart #3 would be just another electric SUV, but after a week driving a Pro model, I’d say it deserves to be on any family EV shortlist.

It feels solid and build quality is hard to fault, while the interior has a classy, quirky feel.

Unusually for an electric car, it is possible to sit fairly low in the #3, which means that you feel more involved on the road.

Smart #3 review

The seats are comfortable and there’s good leg and headroom for rear passengers, despite the roofline. Boot capacity is a so-so 370 litres, increasing to 1,160 litres with the 60:40 split seats folded.

Up front there’s a 9.2-inch driver’s display and 12.8-inch central touchscreen, while higher spec models also get a head-up display.

Sadly, the infotainment system isn’t the most user-friendly, intuitive or responsive I’ve come across.

Smart #3 review

There’s also far too much swiping and prodding for essentials such as climate control, meaning that you’re taking your eye off the road, while the on-screen cartoon avatar is irritating.

As with all new cars, the #3 is fitted with the latest safety and driver assistance kit (it scored a maximum five stars in Euro NCAP crash tests), so expect bongs and beeps aplenty. The driver distraction warning is particularly irritating and sensitive, which is ironic considering it often goes off when you’re trying to find a function on the touchscreen.

On the plus side, the infotainment system comes with Android Auto and Apple CarPlay smartphone mirroring as standard.

Smart #3 review

Inside, there’s a commanding view of the road, but rear visibility isn’t so good, thanks to that sloping roofline and slim tailgate window. It’s also worth noting that there is no rear wiper.

The Smart #3’s set-up is on the stiff side, so it’s not at its best on really poor surfaces, but overall the ride is smooth and comfortable.

Push on and body roll is well contained. There’s also an impressive amount of grip, while the brakes are effective – and progressive, which isn’t always a given with an EV.

Smart #3 review

The steering offers little feedback, but it’s nice to have the option to adjust it (auto, light, standard and heavy), if you can be bothered to tackle the infotainment screen.

The Smart #3 is eager and there are three drive modes (Eco, Comfort and Sport). As ever, Comfort offers the best balance of performance and efficiency, but Sport is fun for short bursts.

Ultimately, it’s more engaging to drive than I thought it would be, but it still doesn’t gain entry to the small club of dynamic EVs on the market.

Smart #3 review

My Smart #3 Pro was efficient, so I’d expect a real-world of between 220-240 miles – more in city driving.

With maximum charge rates of 150kW (66kWh battery) and 130kW (49kWh), both will go from 10-80% in about half an hour. Obviously, they also charge overnight if you have a connection at home.

The Smart #3 comes with a three-year warranty, which is par for the course, but no match for rivals including Hyundai (five years) and Kia (seven years).

Verdict: Competitively-priced, spacious, safe and good to drive, the rakish Smart #3 should be on your shortlist if you’re looking for an electric family SUV that stands out from the crowd.

Smart UK

Smart #1 review

Smart #1 review

We get up to speed with the first of a new generation of Smart cars – the awkwardly-titled #1…

The Smart #1 compact SUV is the first fruit of a new joint venture between Mercedes-Benz and Chinese giant Geely, which also owns Volvo, Polestar and Lotus.

Sharing a platform with the upcoming Volvo EX30, the #1 (pronounced ‘hashtag one’) is a class act and about the same size as a MINI Countryman, Volkswagen ID.3 or Peugeot 2008.

Smart #1 review

Clearly a departure from the iconic city car, the Fortwo, the #1 is likely to transform Smart into a serious player in the EV sector.

Of course, it’s no stranger to electric vehicles. An EV version of the Fortwo was first introduced way back in 2008 and the Smart range has been 100% electric since 2019.

Already crowned Best Small SUV at 2023 What Car? EV Awards, the boldly styled #1 is distinctive, though its rear has a hint of a scaled down Mercedes-Benz EQB.

Smart #1 review

There’s also plenty of scope for personalisation with a wide range of colour and ‘floating’ roof colour combinations.

The clever design continues inside the surprisingly spacious cabin where there’s a quality, slightly quirky feel, and it’s loaded with tech.

As is the trend (unfortunately), the Smart #1 is minimalist up front with just about everything controlled via the 12.8-inch central infotainment screen (Apple CarPlay is integrated, but Android Auto is yet to come).

Smart #1 review

Additionally, all Smart #1s also get a slim 9.2-inch driver’s digital instrument cluster for info such as speed, plus a head-up display is also available on more expensive models.

Thankfully, there are useful shortcuts along the bottom of the main touchscreen, for essentials such as climate control, but you can’t even adjust the wing mirrors without having to access the touchscreen.

On the plus side, the menu structure is intuitive and the screen is responsive. What’s more, the system will save your profile, so it will remember your individual settings every time you drive the car.

Smart #1 review

Personalising settings takes a while, but once you switched off irritating things like Driver Exhaustion Alert, Steering Wheel Re-Centring and Lane Assist, you’re well on your way.

Oh, and there’s also an animated fox lurking on the infotainment screen. It’s a fun face for the voice assistant, and you’ll either find it cute or annoying.

Awarded a maximum five stars in crash testing by Euro NCAP, the #1 is packed with the latest safety and driver assistance systems.

Smart says the #1 has the same interior space as a Mercedes-Benz E-Class, and I don’t doubt it for a moment. There’s plenty of head and leg room throughout and the 60:40 split rear seats recline and slide backwards and forwards.

Smart #1 review

Boot capacity is not best-in-class, ranging between 273 – 411 litres (up to 986 litres with the rear seats flipped), though there is a tiny 15-litre ‘frunk’ under the bonnet.

Competitively priced from £35,950, there are two Smart #1 specs (Pro and Premium) and both get a 66kWh battery pack and a 268bhp motor that drives the rear wheels with 253lb-ft of torque.

Pro models get a reasonable 260-mile range, while Premium is capable of up to 273 miles thanks to the addition of a heat pump and other tech tweaks.

Smart #1 review

Both accelerate from 0-62mph in just 6.7 seconds, while 150kW charging speed means a 10-80% top-up takes as little as 30 minutes.

The Smart #1 is rapid enough as it is, but if you want serious performance, then opt for the range-topping Brabus #1.

Starting at £43,450, this hot all-wheel drive version gets an extra electric motor, develops a huge 422bhp and is capable of 0-62mph in a savagely fast 3.9 seconds. The downside is that the range in the heavier Brabus #1 drops to 248 miles.

Smart #1 review

We tested the Smart #1 Premium and it’s swift, smooth and refined with some of the best road manners in its class. The ride is on the firm side, but it still manages to iron out all but the poorest of surfaces, while wind and road noise are well contained.

Staying surprisingly flat in faster corners, it hides its 1,800kg weight well. Grip levels are impressive too, though it could get a little playful if you floor it in the wet.

It feels especially agile in town, and thanks to a tight turning circle of 11 metres and good visibility, it’s easy to manoeuvre.

Smart #1 review

The Smart #1 is fun on faster, twisty roads, but at its best cruising smoothly.

You can choose between three driving modes – Eco, Comfort and Sport. As ever, Comfort is best for everyday driving. In fact, only throttle response, steering weight and the regenerative brake level are altered anyway.

Like many EVs, the brakes aren’t the most progressive, and the brake regen was a tad fierce for my liking.

Talking of gripes, the driving position is on the high side, but then that’s generally the case with SUVs – particularly electric ones with a battery pack underneath.

Smart #1 review

It’s hard to assess the Smart #1’s real-world range based on a day of driving, but it held its charge well and at least 200 miles would be a reasonable expectation – maybe closer to 240-250 miles in the city.

So, while it may not have a 300-mile range, it’s quick to charge, which means that longer journeys are still a realistic proposition. That said, I suspect the majority of #1s will spend most of their time in urban environments anyway.

Finally, the Smart #1 comes with a three-year unlimited mileage warranty, plus an Integrated Service Package which includes maintenance and MOT, and vehicle wear and tear items for three years/30,000 miles.

Verdict: The Smart #1 small SUV is one of our favourite EVs in the £35-£40,000 price bracket. Swift, spacious and safe, it has a classy, funky feel and delivers an engaging drive.

Smart UK